Compare the spread and commission together, using the same product, position size and trading conditions. The account label does not tell you the total cost.
A provider may offer a wider spread with no separate commission on a particular product, alongside a narrower spread with a commission. Pepperstone’s account explanation illustrates this distinction and also shows why product exceptions matter. This guide uses invented numbers, not its prices or a recommendation to open either account.
Put both accounts on the same basis
Choose one instrument and position size. Confirm what a point or pip means for that contract and its value in the account currency. Then identify whether the stated commission covers one side or both opening and closing. A per-side commission generally needs two legs in a round-trip comparison; minimum commissions and rounding can change the result for small orders.
For an unchanged spread and price, a simple round-trip estimate is: spread × money value per pip + opening commission + closing commission. If spreads differ at entry and exit, a midpoint-based estimate uses half of each spread. Do not add a whole spread to both legs and accidentally double the same cost.
A worked example
Assume one hypothetical position has a value of 10 currency units per pip. The standard account’s spread is 1.2 pips and its separate commission is zero. The raw account’s spread is 0.2 pips and its round-trip commission is 7 units. Assume identical execution, constant spreads and no other fees.
| Account | Calculation | Subtotal |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | 1.2 × 10 | 12 units |
| Raw | 0.2 × 10 + 7 | 9 units |
The raw account is 3 units cheaper under these assumptions. If its spread instead reaches 0.8 pips while the standard quote stays at 1.2, its subtotal becomes 15 units. A minimum advertised spread cannot tell you which of these conditions you will encounter.
Calculate the break-even spread difference
When the standard account has no separate commission, the raw account is cheaper if its spread saving exceeds its commission: (standard spread − raw spread) × pip value > round-trip commission. In the example, the required spread saving is 7 ÷ 10 = 0.7 pips. A 0.7-pip saving produces equal estimated costs; a larger saving favours the raw pricing in this simplified model.
If both commission and spread cost scale proportionally with trade size, simply making more trades does not change which is cheaper per unit. Fixed subscriptions, minimum commissions or volume tiers can alter that relationship. Include them when applicable, but do not increase activity just to reach a fee threshold: extra trading introduces extra costs and risk.
Run the worksheet for the hours and order sizes you actually intend to compare. Keep observed quotes apart from assumptions, and explain any missing inputs instead of treating them as zero.
Add the costs the label leaves out
Repeat the comparison with realistic observed spreads and include financing, currency conversion, platform charges and withdrawals where relevant. Keep slippage separate from the quoted spread. Save each input’s source, entity, currency and date so someone else can reproduce the estimate. Our total-cost guide provides the wider worksheet.
Pricing structure also says nothing about product suitability. ASIC’s CFD guidance explains that leverage magnifies the effect of price changes relative to the margin deposited. A cheaper leveraged trade can still produce a substantial loss. Confirm product availability and the contracting entity before comparing account prices.
Official source
Official sources may open in another language.